The keto diet has been making serious
headway into health and fitness circles in recent years, and I’m sure you’ve
heard a little about it; perhaps enough to know that in one way or another keto
involves (more or less) eating as our ancestors did, with a heavy bias towards
fat, then protein. The goal of keto is to consume as few carbohydrates a day as
possible, and the daily carb limit you’ll most often seen online is 20g.
What is Bone Broth?
Bone broth has been used in cooking for
probably as long as humans have existed as hunter-gatherers. Once all the meat
was gone, our ancestors were left with the bones, fat, connective tissues and
ligaments. These unpalatable items were known to be a good source of food – at
least for animals – and in hard times, people will try anything. Read up on how
harvesting cashews is done, remember that people have been eating them for
thousands of years, and someone had to be the first taste tester.
The simplest method of creating bone broth
is filling up a pot or slow cooker with water and using leftover bones or
carcasses and bones bought especially for the purpose, putting the bones in the
water and cooking it on a low heat for upwards of eight hours, and ideally
twelve to forty-eight hours.
Why Make Bone Broth?
If you read ‘eight to forty-eight hours’
and baulked at the time it takes to make bone broth, don’t worry I did too. I
was also extremely concerned about leaving the house with something on the
stove, so I did the only reasonable thing: I researched the pros and cons of bone
broth to see if it was worth the risk and time.
The Pros
1. It’s cheap to make
Bone broth can be made using the bones of
any animals and supplemented with extras like apple cider vinegar to draw out
nutrients, spices and vegetables, but the simplest version is water, bones and
salt. You can pick up bones or carcasses from your local supermarket or butcher
quite cheaply or use any leftovers from the bone-in meat you use in your
day-to-day life.
It doesn’t take a lot of bones to make
enough bone broth for a week or two and it’s a versatile base for a lot of
meals. Whether it be a cup of hot broth on its own, using it to flavour stir
fries, make soup or any other meal, it is a budget friendly addition to your
diet.
2. It’s high in collagen
Some studies have found that collagen
(specifically collagen hydrolysate) can help reduce the joint deterioration in
high risk groups like active sportspeople or the elderly[i].
Bone broth is a very good source of collagen because of the length of time you
simmer the bones over a low heat. They and the connective tissues are a rich
source of collagen, so when you cook them the nutrients leach into water where
they’re more available for digestion. The gelatin boosts cartilage to reduce
friction between bones and and helps
support bone density production[ii].
Another side effect of the collagen is that
it can also increase the health of your skin and hair[iii].
Drinking bone broth provides your body with more collagen, giving your body the
extra boost it needs to produce more keratin the strengthen your skin, nails
and hair.
3. It helps you sleep
Bone broth contains an amino acid called
glycine. While it’s non-essential, one study found that glycine improves sleep
quality in patients with restricted sleep patterns[iv].
People who ingest 3g or more of glycine on a regular basis demonstrate a
reduction in fatigue and general reduced sleepiness. Interestingly, both the
objective assessment and the patient’s self-assessment showed similar results.
The study specifically focusses on glycine
taken during the evening, so for all those insomniacs out there, a regular diet
or drink of bone broth could help you fall asleep. At a minimum you would feel
the effect of poor sleep less.
Without going into too much detail, glycine
helps regulate your body’s internal clock[v]
(it’s a part of the hypothalamus gland) and this is what helps your body
maintain the usual level of alertness during the daylight hours.
4. Bone broth is good for the digestion
Bone broth is easily digestible and
soothing to the stomach because the gelatin in the broth[vi]
helps support intestinal integrity, reducing the chances of a leaky gut by
sealing the holes in the intestines. It is believed one reason for this is that
gelatin both helps the growth of good bacteria in the gut and reduces the
effects of food sensitivities.
5. It’s a fast, tasty meal
Now this is entirely subjective, but I find
bone broth (I usually make chicken broth) to be very tasty in and of itself, or
as part of egg drop soup. After an eight hour day and two hours of commuting it
can be a hassle to cook. However, heating up a bowl full of broth takes mere
minutes; less if you happen to own a microwave.
Are There Any Cons?
Aside from the process being time
consuming, I only found one notable negative point, and it would be remiss for
me not to mention it. Bone broth contains high levels of glutamic acid and
glutamate[vii].
For a small percentage of the population, these two nutrients can provoke
seizures or other neurological symptoms like brain fog and migraine headaches.
If you start experiencing these effects after trying bone broth, stop
immediately and use meat stock instead.
The Balance
For me, I found that making bone broth is
more than worth the initial effort and learning how to make it. I’ve used bone
broth to flavour all my meals, in soups, stews and casseroles and yes, even
just as a drink. There’s something very homey and relaxing about settling down
with a cup of subtly meaty, salty broth. That said, my favourite way to use
bone broth is when I’m pan searing meat or sauteeing vegetables. It adds
another level of flavour without having to put any real effort into cooking.
Making Bone Broth
Ingredients
I’ve been living with an improvised kitchen
for several years, so my way of making bone broth is based on having minimal
equipment. The absolute minimum equipment needed is a hot plate, a large pot, a
spoon, some tupperware containers and a sieve or strainer.
My personal preference for making bone
broth is:
- two chicken carcasses
- one onion, halved
- 7 oz./200g of button mushrooms (but
any mushroom would work)
- 4 cloves of minced garlic
- the top and bottom of one small
carrot
- a pinch of salt
- cumin
Personally, I find that adding too much
carrot creates a sweeter broth than I like, so I either add the carrot ends
halfway through the cooking process or remove them after several hours. The
mushrooms give it a good umami flavour and the salt is said to draw out
more nutrients. I have a preference for chicken broth because it’s mild enough
to work with anything and the carcasses were cheaper than pork of beef bones.
A word of warning on the salt. Only add a
little bit because you will be reducing the broth down significantly and this
will increase the saltiness of the mix. The best way to find the right level of
saltiness for you is to carefully increase the amount of salt you use each time
you make another batch of broth.
The Process
I basically throw all the ingredients into
the pot and fill up the pot until the water just covers the top of carcasses or
bones that I use. Set it to a low heat, put the lid on the pot and leave it for
as long as you can. The longest I’ve simmered bone broth is fifteen hours or
so, but I don’t have a slow cooker to regulate things for me.
The most hands-on part of making the broth
comes at the very end. It’s also the most annoying part by far, especially if
you’re working without a real kitchen and have limited counter space. You have
to strain the entire mixture at least to get out the smaller parts of bone,
cartilage, meat and vegetables as well as the large ones that you can scoop out
with a spoon. It must be left to cool properly before you put the lid on
the pot and refrigerate it. Broth can be frozen as well to extend the life of
it.
Summary
Bone broth is a nutrient dense[viii],
low-calorie stock that you can use in many meals, and it has several notable
positive effects on the body, including reducing sleepiness and improving
digestion. While it can be bought as broth cubes or as a fully made broth
straight from a supermarket, it’s considered healthier to make it from scratch
at home in order to control what goes into your bone broth.
Sources:
[i] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18416885 Accessed 06 Jun 2019.
[ii] https://draxe.com/the-healing-power-of-bone-broth-for-digestion-arthritis-and-cellulite/
Accessed 06 Jun 2019.
[iii] https://facty.com/lifestyle/wellness/10-healthy-reasons-to-have-bone-broth/ Accessed 06 Jun 2019.
[iv] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3328957/
Accessed 06 Jun 2019.
[v] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10548871 Accessed 06 Jun 2019.
[vi] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3358810/ Accessed 06 Jun 2019.
[vii] https://www.seleneriverpress.com/the-dark-side-of-bone-broth/
Accessed 06 Jun 2019.